A question posed beautifully in a new way, but not a new question.
The human mind is not capable of grasping the Universe. We are like a little child entering a huge library. The walls are covered to the ceilings with books in many different tongues. The child knows that someone must have written these books. It does not know who or how. It does not understand the languages in which they are written. But the child notes a definite plan in the arrangement of the books - a mysterious order which it does not comprehend, but only dimly suspects. -- Albert Einstein
We have found a strange footprint on the shores of the unknown. We have devised profound theories, one after another, to account for its origins. At last, we have succeeded in reconstructing the creature that made the footprint. And lo! It is our own. -- Sir Arthur Eddington
It is wrong to think that the task of physics is to find out how Nature is. Physics concerns what we say about Nature. -– Niels Bohr
Posted by danae at February 14, 2005 2:05 AMAye; poetic, but not new. Evoking Sagan here was deft.
Empiricism, also, needs such poetic apologeia, to respond both to what seems our natural feeling of wonder, and to our need to explain; the bifurcate nature of being human.
They are not separate qualities, but symbiotic.
Posted by kobekko at February 14, 2005 5:50 AMScience is pure magick: to name a phemonenon is to tame it.
p.s. danae's quote from Bohr is perfect for what you wrote. Nice piece, nice response.
Posted by Oscar at February 14, 2005 6:14 AM You might like to know that bioluminescence is
a phenomena that is different colors across the
globe. Bluish where you are and greeninsh in the
South China Sea.
The altar of science exists only as long as we
worship there and stop asking questions.
Nicely done, although your vision of scientists as modern-day priests is a bit disingenuous. Unlike most religions, which adhere to unchanging orthodoxies, science approaches the world as it is. Scientists seek out facts and let the facts speak to them about the nature of our world. Those who don't understand this are easy marks for creationists and other seeking to advance religion by posing as men of science.
Posted by Philomathean at February 14, 2005 11:37 AMNot the emotion you were probably going for but what your piece made me feel was a bit of envy.
I envy you for being able to write this well. And I envy you for the fact that your home overlooks the Pacific Ocean (my water view is of my neighbor's pool).
Very well done piece.
I would say that science and religion are not mutually exclusive though. The bible says that God created the earth in seven days but who is to say what constitutes a day for God? The Big Bang Theory explains how the universe was created but what explains what existed before the Big Bang? I would also point out that the word "bioluminescence" also has its roots in arcane Latin phrases.
Posted by chris at February 14, 2005 11:39 AMWith regard to the majestic mysteries of the universe,the infinite compexities of the natural wonders, one can only ask:
"What about Bacchus?!!"
Wow!!! a Google search on Eucharist/light/Einstein brought me face-to-face with your profound comments.
While they differ in perspective from my own---by 180 degrees---I think they might open eyes, an as antithetical view to the Truth that I believe.
One question looms...is this a satire relating the sad state of a world that has made science a religon, or do you really believe in the canon of secular saints?
My kids and I are anxiously awaiting the PBS Special EINSTEIN's BIG IDEA on October 11th. I don't think we will hear a word about Einstein's youth and relationship to the Catholic Church, but I pray that his communication with the "Old One" is portrayed for all to see.
Last week when I read the Pope Benedict's Angelus comments from his summer residence I was struck by his remark, "The Eucharist becomes in this way the source of the spiritual energy that renews our life every day and, in this way, renews the love of Christ to the world."
As you might recall in his homily to 800,000 motivated young Catholics at the closing Mass of World Youth Day, the Holy Father spoke of the Eucharist with words packed with meaning, "This is like inducing nuclear fission in the very heart of being -- the victory of love over hatred, the victory of love over death," he said. "Only this intimate explosion of good conquering evil can then trigger off the series of transformations that little by little will change the world."
And his profound "dictatorship of relativism" from April remains permanently etched in our consciousness.
For the past ten months I have been attempting to share what I believe is a key to this "Year of the Eucharist" and the Church's New Evangelization, however I am neither a scholar, nor a very good communicator. My qualifications as a former Army Infantry Officer mean little to the world of theology and religion.
I am by the grace of God, a late-in-life husband and a father of two young boys (so far.) My family serves full-time as lay missionaries for the Society of Our Lady of the Most Holy Trinity, SOLT, a religious order that was founded forty-seven years ago in the Sangre de Christo Mountains of New Mexico.
I deeply know and love the Catholic Faith and believe fully in God's Providence. I have experienced it firsthand---often in dramatic fashion---these past seven years of my adult life. I was shown the power and love of Jesus' Divine Mercy at my reversion (4-16-98) when I was exposed to the light that beamed from a silver cross of a Deacon Joe Hromadka (he was ordained a priest at age 79, this past July here in Corpus Christi). From that moment on, my constant prayer has been to serve humbly and faithfully in the Lord's vineyard.
Near the end of a year of intense research for a fledgling book project, I drafted the twelve page "paper." I have tried and seemingly failed to get it into the mainstream to help jump start the "burning bush." My concept was simple---to get others (more talented than I) curious enough to follow a lead to learn what I did.
Writing a book was not an option, for I know my limitations.
Since last December we Americans have witnessed over a dozen significant events that involve matters that I discussed. I say this not to testify to any prophetic gift, but to tell you that I have received strong confirmation that compels me to continue trying share the truth of what burns in my heart.
We are now witnessing the final events of a year that has been filled with coincidence---not luck, synchronicity or accident, but Providence---for the Eucharistic Year Synod in Rome coincides with the two-hour PBS/NOVA Special on Albert Einstein.
Please take ten minutes to read the paper at www.soltlaity.org/breadoflife.htm.
(You'll notice a lack of documentation but be rest assured, this "broad brush stroke" of a paper is supported by so many different primary sources that to start parsing how credit is distributed would unduly burden the reader)
If you'd like to review a sample of some of the more than 125 slides that support the the ideas contained in the paper go to www.soltlaity.org/slideshow.htm.
I have been praying that I would find someone with whom I might collaborate, to bring the key research findings into the public eye. Dialogue, with the goal of becoming more LIGHT and TRUTH sensitive, that is the key.
I can be reached at jmjriz@aol.com, at the office at 361-767-9417 or on my cell at 361-563-2602.
God bless you for your great efforts at shining His Light.
Sincerely yours,
Mike Rizzio, SOLT
Imitate Mary, Become like Jesus, Live for the Triune God